A note on sources. I am a game developer, not a historian. Where I make a historical claim I have listed the source at the end. Where the sources disagree, I say so instead of picking the tidier version.

When I designed the faces of the chests in Royal Chest, I settled on six carved symbols: a crown, a sword, a shield, a key, a chalice and a scroll. The gems that spill out when a chest opens are treasure rather than signs, and they follow their own rules. When I picked the six, I assumed the history would be straightforward — that each object arrived with a tidy medieval meaning I could lean on. It is not tidy. What I found instead was a set of symbols whose main job was not to express feelings at all. Their job was to identify people, claim authority, and record who owned what.

That turned out to be a much better fit for a game about locked chests than the version I had in my head.

The symbol chart is a modern invention

Search for "heraldic colour meanings" and you will find confident tables. Gold means generosity. Silver means peace. Red means courage. Blue means loyalty. Black means constancy. Those lists are everywhere, reproduced from book to book, and they are mostly late: many of the tidiest ones were assembled in the seventeenth century and after, and they disagree with each other on nearly every entry.

Medieval people absolutely did read moral meanings into things. Bestiaries moralised animals, lapidaries moralised stones, sermons moralised numbers. But that was a general habit of thought, not a decoding key for a coat of arms. A. C. Fox-Davies, whose Complete Guide to Heraldry of 1909 is still a standard reference, treats heraldry as a system of identification first and a system of meaning a distant second. Michel Pastoureau's work makes the point even more directly: arms told you whose son you were looking at and what he claimed. They were a signature, and signatures do not have feelings.

This matters for design, because it changes what a symbol is allowed to do. If a sword means courage, it is a poster. If a sword means lawful force and the right to use it, it can sit on a lock and mean something.

The crown: the arches were a political claim

The most meaningful part of a crown is the part almost nobody looks at: the arches.

An open crown — a band with points, or with fleurs-de-lis — was a crown. A crown closed by arches was a claim. The Royal Household's own account of the Imperial State Crown says it plainly: the term dates to the fifteenth century, when English monarchs chose a design closed by arches to demonstrate that England was not subject to any other earthly power. The arches are not ornament. They are the visual equivalent of "no one above me".

St Edward's Crown, made for Charles II in 1661 to replace the medieval crown melted down in 1649, keeps the formula: four crosses-pattée, four fleurs-de-lis, two arches, an orb and a cross on top. It is a replacement of a replacement, and it still reads as a claim of sovereignty at a glance, which is presumably why it keeps being used.

In Royal Chest, the crown symbol has closed arches. Not because every chest belongs to a king, but because at twenty-four pixels across the arches are the one feature that separates "crown" from "unusually elaborate hat". The history and the legibility test happened to want the same thing, which is rarer than you would think.

The sword: justice, mercy, and a blunt tip

Coronation swords are carried point up. The Royal Household is explicit about this for all three swords used in the coronation procession, and it is worth knowing before you draw one: an upward point reads as authority, a downward point reads as violence.

Those three swords are also a lesson in how symbolism layers. The Sword of Temporal Justice stands for the monarch as head of the armed forces. The Sword of Spiritual Justice stands for the defender of the faith. And Curtana, the Sword of Mercy, has a blunted tip. Same object, three meanings, separated by context and, in one case, a piece of filed steel.

Real medieval swords were rarely as singular as the legends claim either. Joyeuse, the coronation sword of the French kings, is now in the Louvre, and the museum's catalogue entry is a small act of honesty: the pommel is tenth or eleventh century, the quillons twelfth, the grip thirteenth or fourteenth, and the blade eighteenth or nineteenth. The sword is first mentioned in a written inventory in 1271, and it was kept at the treasury of Saint-Denis until the Revolution. It is a composite assembled and repaired across nine hundred years, and it is still called Charlemagne's sword.

I find that comforting. The objects we treat as ancient and singular are usually a pile of later decisions with an old story attached. A game about chests that are not quite what they seem can lean on that.

The shield: grammar, not emotion

A shield in heraldry is an escutcheon, and it works like grammar rather than vocabulary. You get a field, a set of tinctures, and a handful of rules. The metals are gold (or) and silver (argent); the colours are red (gules), blue (azure), black (sable), green (vert) and purple (purpure). The central constraint — never place metal on metal or colour on colour — exists to keep a shield readable at distance: on a banner, a seal, a gate, or a muddy field.

That is a design rule, not a moral system, and it is the same rule I face in Royal Chest. The shield symbol in the game is a blue escutcheon with a single gold band: two tinctures, one rule, readable in peripheral vision. When I tested twenty-three palette variations for the game, the blue-and-gold pairing was the one that survived every check, including deuteranopia simulation, where several of my earlier green-on-red ideas collapsed into a single muddy shape.

The rule of tincture is also why heraldry looks the way it does. If you have ever wondered why medieval arms seem so chunky and flat, it is not a lack of artistic skill. It is contrast, deliberately maximised for identification at fifty paces.

The key: a symbol that is also a function

Keys are the only symbol in Royal Chest whose meaning is literal. A key locks and unlocks. That is the whole idea, and it is also, more or less, the whole medieval idea.

The theological version is the famous one: in the Gospel of Matthew, Christ tells Peter, "I will give you the keys of the kingdom of heaven." That sentence became the crossed keys of papal arms and the image of Saint Peter holding a key the size of his forearm.

The practical version is more relevant to a game about chests. Keys were an office. The chamberlain carried the keys to the treasury chamber; the chatelain carried the keys to the castle; a city presented its keys to a visiting sovereign at the gate, a ceremony about submission dressed as hospitality. To hold a key was to hold delegated authority over one specific object in one specific place — and everyone who saw you holding it knew exactly that.

That is why the key became the plate marker on locked faces in Royal Chest. It does not need a legend. It says: this section is not yours yet.

The chalice: a bowl that became the Grail

Medieval chalices were usually silver-gilt, with a shallow bowl on a stem, and they were made to be lifted, not to be casually drunk from. The bowl matters more than the stem: a wide, shallow bowl catches light across its whole surface, which is why it still reads as a cup in silhouette.

The Grail is a different story, and a useful corrective to how we picture medieval objects. In Chrétien de Troyes' Perceval, written around 1180, the grail is a serving dish carried in a procession. It is not obviously a cup, and it is not yet the cup of the Last Supper. It becomes that vessel a generation later, in Robert de Boron's retelling around 1200, where the grail is the dish of the Last Supper and the vessel in which Joseph of Arimathea caught Christ's blood. Richard Barber's history of the legend traces how much of what we "know" about the Grail is medieval invention that hardened into canon.

So the golden cup of every film is a later layer on top of a serving dish. In the game, the chalice symbol is purple and has a wide bowl, because a wide bowl survives being scaled down to a thumbnail better than the tall goblet everyone expects. Function beat iconography.

The scroll: property and memory

Most medieval records were not books. They were rolls: parchment sheets sewn end to end and rolled up. The English Exchequer kept pipe rolls from the twelfth century onward — the earliest surviving one dates from 1130 — and the Chancery kept charter rolls, close rolls and patent rolls. A sealed charter was how a grant of land or a right was proved, and Magna Carta survives in multiple copies precisely because it was sealed and distributed, with later reissues enrolled on the rolls.

For a game about locked chests, the scroll is the most useful symbol of the six. A chest is a container. A scroll is a record of who owns what is inside the container. Put a scroll on a chest and the object stops being neutral: somebody claimed it, somebody wrote it down, and the writing is the reason the lock exists.

It also gave me a way to explain the sealed-chamber levels without dialogue. The scroll does not say "treasure". It says "title".

What I left out, and why

My first symbol set had eleven. I cut five, and the cuts were more interesting than the additions.

  • The cross. I am not comfortable using a religious symbol as one more collectible on a treasure chest. It is also a legibility problem: at small sizes a cross reads as a plus sign.
  • The fleur-de-lis. Too tied to one monarchy's claim, and its silhouette collides with the crown once the crown includes fleurs. Two symbols that look alike are one symbol with extra steps.
  • The skull. Wrong century for a castle chest, and it pulls the whole palette toward piracy. Every pirate game has one; I did not want the association.
  • The lion. Heraldry's most common charge and its most complicated silhouette. A lion rampant at twenty-four pixels is a smudge.
  • The dragon. Same problem as the lion, worse.

What is left is six symbols that pass a test I settled on early. It has to read at twenty-four pixels, in one colour, in peripheral vision. It needs one dominant silhouette with no thin appendages. It should imply what happens to the chest: open it, match it, lock it. And it must still be findable in grayscale. The cross failed the silhouette test, which gave me a second, more honest reason to leave it out.

Colour is a promise the interface must keep

None of this symbolism survives bad colour. Gold #C9A84C, purple #6B3FA0 and stone #8B8B8B carry the game. The final palette passed WCAG AA contrast on every main pairing, and I checked each combination in deuteranopia and protanopia simulation before shipping. The colours are not there to mean virtue. They are there to keep six symbols distinct on a five-inch screen at 60% brightness, in a waiting room, at night.

The rule I settled on

History is texture, not a test. If you recognise the object, the history did its job. If you can solve the puzzle without ever thinking about the history, the design did its job. The moment a symbol needs a caption to be understood, it has stopped being a symbol and become a footnote.

That is why the crown has arches you will never consciously count, why the sword points up, why the shield obeys a twelfth-century rule you will only ever feel as "that looks right", and why the scroll is rolled instead of flat. None of it is a history lesson. All of it is the reason the chests look the way they do.

The six Royal Chest symbols and their historical anchors
Symbol What it signalled A concrete anchor In the game
Crown Sovereignty; closed arches meant no earthly superior St Edward's Crown, 1661: four crosses-pattée, four fleurs-de-lis, two arches Closed-arch silhouette, readable at 24 px
Sword Lawful force and the right to use it Curtana, the Sword of Mercy, carried with a blunted tip Upright, single silhouette, no gore
Shield Identity of a person or lineage Rule of tincture: metal on colour, never colour on colour Azure field with one gold band
Key Delegated authority over one object or place Matthew 16:19; civic keys offered at the gate Marks the plate on a locked face
Chalice The Eucharist; later, the Grail Chrétien de Troyes' serving dish, c. 1180 Wide purple bowl that survives thumbnailing
Scroll Record, title, and the claim behind a lock Pipe rolls from 1130; sealed charters Sealed-chamber levels, no dialogue needed